<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=591165851039736&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">
blog-icon

Case Studies

Mar 24, 2022 12:43:10 PM by Lauren Mangano

Mitsubishi Ductless AC Replacement in Boathouse Row, Philadelphia Following Flood Damage

PROBLEM: The air conditioning units outside Fairmount Rowing Association along Boathouse Row, Philadelphia were damaged during Hurricane Ida's massive flooding. As a result, the boathouse was left with no AC and therefore needed a new solution for their cooling needs.

SOLUTION: ECI Comfort replaced the five indoor ductless air handlers with brand new Mitsubishi ductless models. The five new outdoor units were relocated to the opposite side of the building where flooding is less likely. They were also mounted high on the wall instead of the ground so that they will not be reached in the event of another flood.

 
 
 
 

When Hurricane Ida struck in early September 2021, the city of Philadelphia really felt the effects of the flooding. Fire Commissioner Adam Thiel stated that the river was at heights not seen in more than 150 years, according to an article by NPR. Flooding closes the Vine Street Expressway from Broad Street to the Schuylkill River.

Historic Boathouse Row, which sits right along the Schuylkill River and Kelly Drive, was of course hit hard by the flooding. Where we usually see the charming Boathouse Row lights was the aftermath of a destructive hurricane. And while the members of these boathouses had certainly seen flooding before, this was nothing like they were used to. 

Hurricane Ida flooding Boathouse Row

John Krajewski, president of Fairmount Rowing Association, was one of many veteran rowers who were unprepared for the damage. As seen in the picture below, Hurricane Irene of 2011 hit the garage of his boathouse about knee or thigh-deep. The storm that hit in 2014 was a bit higher than Irene, but still nothing too damaging.  Hurricane Ida, on the other hand, almost reached the top of the garage door. "It ripped structural supports right off the wall," John explained. "The boats actually rose with the flooding and destroyed all the racks."

Hurricane Ida flooding Fairmount Rowing Association

Not only this, but the water also rose over their air conditioning units, completely frying them. With another hot summer not too far away, John knew he needed to get them replaced. That's where ECI came in. 

Want to see an overview of this project? Watch the video below.Boathouse Row Episode 1

History of Fairmount Rowing Association

Considering the extensive history of the association, it's pretty significant that this was one of the highest floods they've ever seen.

Fairmount Rowing Association (FRA), located at 2 Boathouse Row, Philadelphia, Pa., is home to a rowing club that was founded in 1877. They are primarily a Masters rowing club, meaning it is mostly post-collegiate. The once small team started out holding meetings in a room on Fairmount Avenue and was eventually able to purchase a six-oar barge which they stored in an old building. Members had to carry the boat six blocks to the river to row, according to their website. Later down the road in July of 1881, the club purchased the southern half of #2 Boathouse Row from Pacific Barge Club.

When speaking to John about the association's history, he explained how they've been rowing there since the 1800s. "These buildings evolved where there were just boats left on the shore, then they became shacks, to semi-permanent instructors, and finally somebody came in and said 'if you guys are going to put houses here, they're going to have to be constructed properly,' and that's what you see today. There are 15 houses on the river here today." 

Want to hear John tell us more about the history of FRA? Watch the video below. Boathouse Row Episode 2

Boathouse Row & Kelly Drive, Philadelphia

In 1904, Fairmount tore down their half and had architect Walter Smedley replace it with a two-and-a-half-story brick structure in the Georgian Revival style. And in 1916, the club was allowed to join the Schuylkill Navy after decades of being rejected. 

Fast forward to the '40s when FRA purchased the adjacent association, Quaker City Barge Club. The club had fallen on hard times, so under the leadership of John Carlin, the two boathouses were combined to become one association. Quaker City now serves as the northern half of Fairmount Rowing's boathouse. One side was opened up and connected to the other with a bar and kitchen area, which was driven by John Kiefer. They now use the space to host receptions, wedding rehearsals, and other events!John Carlin - Fairmount Rowing Association

The stained glass windows below represent both Fairmount and Quaker City. The "Wall of Fame" lives to the right of the Quaker City window and features those like Tereza Bell who won the Silver medal in the  Lightweight Women's Double at the 1996 Olympics. John also told us about Ted Nash, who was one of the most attended American at the Olympics ever, either as a coach or rower. In between the two windows, the Members in Service are featured. It displays Fairmount Rowing's members that served in World War II. Fairmount Rowing Association and Quaker City Barge Club

It's clear that the history of this boathouse is extensive, and that's why replacing the AC units with new, non-intrusive units that don't damage the boathouse's integrity was important. And, as John stated himself, he and the 150 or so members "row until the river is unrowable". We wanted to make sure that after each long day of rowing, the members could come inside to a cool, comfortable house.

Initial Discussions

After dealing with the damage from the storm, John Krajewski, president of Fairmount Rowing Association, realized the boathouse's HVAC units were affected. While the warm weather was coming to an end for the year and the air conditioning wasn't an urgent fix, it was clear that they would need to be replaced before the upcoming summer. 

That's why John called ECI soon after to request a consultation for new ductless air conditioners.Contact ECI Comfort

In an older building like this, finding an efficient cooling solution can be tough. To design ductwork or some sort of conventional system to fit in this space without any major renovations is a difficult process. In order to maintain the integrity of the building but still get suitable cooling, the best option was a ductless mini-split.

We landed on replacing the five indoor ductless mini-splits which were re-run to different locations for the five new outdoor condensers. Because all of the previous outdoor units were flooded over -- around six feet high -- we decided that mounting the new ones high up on the opposite wall would be safest. That way, in the event of another flood, they won't be affected.

The Install

Want to see the install in action? Watch the video below.

Boathouse Row Episode 3

Relocating the outdoor units

The install crew got started at 8 a.m. the first day to restore the boathouse's cooling comfort. As stated above, they re-ran the lines to connect the indoor air conditioning units to the newly located outdoor units. The linesets are what allow refrigerant to flow through and produce cool air in each room/zone. By moving the outdoor units, we also shortened some of these linesets, which will allow the units to work more efficiently and prevent rooms from overheating. This is especially important for rooms like the bar area, where the combination of the afternoon sunlight and the crowding from guests and caterers causes the room to overheat easily.

Variable-speed compressors

Another benefit of these new units is the variable-speed compressors, which will also help create even, comfortable cooling. Whereas other units waste power by turning on each time you need AC and back off when you don’t, these systems steadily provide cool air to maintain precise temperatures in each room. Take a look at the quick video from Mitsubishi below to get a visual of how it works.

More benefits of ductless

The third main benefit of ductless air conditioning systems is that they are non-intrusive and less complex to install. Rather than doing major renovations to install ductwork throughout the boathouse, all we need are small holes in the wall to run the lines through. In addition, the single-zone units allow for personalized temperature control in each area. If one room is sunnier than the other and needs more cool air, it's no problem with ductless. Take a look at the short video below to how it works.

Schedule Your Free Ductless Consultation

Completing the installation

Want to see the completed installation + hear more about Fairmount's history? Watch the video below.Boathouse Row Episode 4

Over the course of three days at Boathouse Row, our install crew worked to remove the old units, mount the new ones outside, install the new ones inside, run the refrigerant lines, and connect the power. Installing the linesets included insulating them to prevent condensation on the fittings. If you don’t insulate everything, water can drip out and lead to mold. And the last thing we need inside this boathouse is more unwanted water.

Mounting the outdoor units required securing them to brackets so that they safely stay in space. Placing them high on the wall will keep them out of the way of water, as mentioned earlier, and will also open up more room on the ground where the old units were.

After running the electricity, connecting power to the HVAC system, and testing the system for leaks, the crew was finished with the replacement. Check out the old units versus one of the new condensers below!

Mitsubishi air conditioning installation in Philadelphia

We also painted the previously white line-hide to match the blue color of the walls inside, as seen below. This little touch will help them blend in better so that visitors can focus on the memorabilia, trophies, and paintings that keep the boathouse’s history front and center. Line hide for ductless mini split

We'll touch base with John and the members of Fairmount Rowing Association this spring/summer to find out how everything is working for them!


Schedule Your Free Ductless Consultation
ECI Comfort specializes in installing Mitsubishi Ductless Mini-Splits in Philadelphia, PA. If you are interested or would like to know more, click the button above or reach us at (215) 245-3200 or info@ecicomfort.com!
 
 

This entry was posted in Commercial Heating And Cooling, Safety, Mitsubishi Electric, Ductless, Air Conditioning, Philadelphia, PA, Fairmount, Philadelphia